My Info

Andrew Nicholl Profile Photo

Andrew Nicholl

 Senior Sales Associate, PSA 
8534 Yankee St, Washington Township, OH 45458

I am extraordinarily passionate about working with people. There is something very rewarding in being able to journey through life with my clients and helping them make the important decisions in buying or selling their home.


No matter the situation, my clients are my top priority. I am in their corner and want the absolute best for them. With everything going through their mind during a move, I want to walk with them. My only goal is to ensure my clients have the very best Real Estate experience.


I have been married to my beautiful bride, Courtney, since 2007 and we have two young children that continue to teach us the ideas in life that really matter. After graduating from Cedarville University, I served as a worship pastor in Centerville for 12 years until starting my career in real estate.


My Achievements:

National Association of Realtors

- Pricing Strategy Adivisor, PSA (2020)

- REALTOR designation (2016)


Ohio Realtors

  - Award of Distinction (2018-20)


Dayton Realtors 

- Award of Excellence (2020)

- Award of Distinction (2019)

- Award of Achievement (2018)

- Dayton Realtors Top 5 Under 40 (2018)


Coldwell Banker 

  - Internationals President's Circle (2019-20)

  - International Diamond Society (2018)

  - Coldwell Banker International Sterling Society (2017)


Coldwell Banker Heritage 
 - Senior Sales Associate (2020)

 - #14th Agent at Coldwell Banker Heritage (2020)

 - #16th Agent at Coldwell Banker Heritage (2019)

 - #19th Agent at Coldwell Banker Heritage (2018)

 - Rookie of the Year (2017)

What my clients are saying (6)

My Service Ratings

12/26/2020 - drewfus382

Andrew was fantastic for us. Very quick and easy sale of our old house for more than the asking price, and worked his tail off for us on the purchase of our new one. Would recommend him anytime.

Zillow Logo

My Service Ratings

08/22/2019 - Daniel i stovall

Andrew was awesome. We were in a situation where we had received job offers in another city and had a limited amount of time to get our house listed and sold. Andrew came alongside us and walked us through the process (this is the first house we've sold). Not only does he have a great attitude and he's easy to work with, he is super knowledgeable about the local area. We had last minute repairs we needed to do and he helped us track down contractors. He also knows the market really well and I believe he did a really good job knowing where to price our house. He is also good working with other agents in the area and he has a great reputation. Feeling like you can really trust your agent is a big deal for me, and I really felt like we could be completely honest with Andrew as we went through the process. If there was something we didn't understand, he took the time to get us up to speed. Even though selling a house can be stressful, I was very grateful we had someone like Andrew to work with during this transition. If you're looking to sell a home in the Dayton area, especially around Centerville/Washington Township, you should hire Andrew.

Zillow Logo

My Service Ratings

06/30/2018 - nancyhuff

Andrew was a phenomenal realtor for our family! He went above and beyond in finding the perfect home for us even thinking outside the box!! We had a great time looking at properties together and kept a flexible schedule to accommodate our needs!

Zillow Logo

Active Listings (5)

5 Stansel CT Property Photo
Beds: 4
Baths: 4 Total
SqFt: 3,793
2509 Adirondack TRL Property Photo
Beds: 3
Baths: 3 Total
SqFt: 1,922
2013 Kenway Place Property Photo
Beds: 3
Baths: 3 Total
SqFt: 1,777
2013 Kenway PL Property Photo
Beds: 3
Baths: 3 Total
SqFt: 1,777
612 Alexander DR Property Photo
Beds: 3
Baths: 2 Total
SqFt: 864

Contact Me